Andy Burnham at LPC

Does our Prime Minister have too much power or too little?

In 1976, in a lecture on the BBC, Lord Hailsham criticised Harold Wilson’s government suggesting that we were close to an “elective dictatorship.” His point was that under the British constitution, a Prime Minister with a large working majority in the House of Commons has virtually unlimited power. Hailsham said that the only limitations on that power were: “political and moral. They are found in the consciences of members, in the necessity for periodical elections, and in the so-called checks and balances inherent in the composition, structure and practice of Parliament itself.” That certainly sounds like too much power.

On the other hand, we are constantly told that, given the state of UK government finances, and the Chancellor’s very limited headroom, there is very little that the government can do to deliver the national renewal which it has promised, and which the population as a whole so badly needs. That sounds like too little.

In reality, the Prime Minister has too much power, but exercises too little:

  • The Prime Minister has been conditioned to operate, not just within the constitution but within a framework set by our institutions and our media – within that framework, he has too little power to deliver national renewal;
  • As Lord Hailsham pointed out, the constitution gives him virtually unlimited power – and that is clearly too much;
  • Paradoxically, therefore, the Prime Minister should both exercise more power in the national interest and cede more to prevent bad actors from abusing that power in the future.

We need our governments to use their power for the good of the country

The BBC cites one civil servant as saying that politicians “are increasingly like children. Agog and overawed at winning office and too frightened to do anything with it once they are there.”

That sounds as if it is a personal failing on the part of our leaders, and ultimately, perhaps it is. But the reality is that a new leader becomes Prime Minister or Chancellor within a framework which has built up over the last 45 years, which makes action extremely difficult.

Relaxed media ownership laws, and the parachuting-in of right-wing figures at the top of the BBC, combined with the ownership of the large social media platforms by the far-right mean that any progressive action is likely to be misrepresented in the media and come with a high political cost.

And at the same time, as we argued in our report Ending Treasury-Induced Decline, new institutions and frameworks like the fiscal rules, the Bank of England’s independence on inflation management and the creation of the Office for Budget responsibility, mean that rather than supporting the government in its actions, our institutions resist anything other than a Budget which produces further cuts to government spending. And, as the real story of Liz Truss’s Budget shows, that resistance can be fatal.

So it is understandable, if no longer pardonable, if a Prime Minister decides to operate within the constraints that have built up over recent decades.

Our argument is clear: that way leads to continued decline. The government must be bold enough to change the constraints to make national renewal possible.

But can it really do so?

The Government has virtually unlimited power

Lord Hailsham was right: our Prime Ministers have too much power. As the parliamentary website sets out,

“Parliamentary sovereignty is a principle of the UK constitution. It makes Parliament the supreme legal authority in the UK, which can create or end any law. Generally, the courts cannot overrule its legislation and no Parliament can pass laws that future Parliaments cannot change. Parliamentary sovereignty is the most important part of the UK constitution.”

A Prime Minister with a working majority can pass any legislation: it can reduce the power of the courts, it can take control of the media, it can remove all our human rights, it can cease any benefits and public services it wishes to, it can raise or lower taxes at will. It can change the frequency of general elections. It can do anything that is physically possible.

Lord Hennessy coined the phrase “The good chaps theory of politics.” His point was that our constitution relies on the idea that although our politicians may be more or less capable, they are trying to do what they believe is for the good of the country. They will not exercise that tremendous power for ill.

But if we look at the United States, a country which has a constitution designed to prevent a slide into tyranny, we can see clearly what happens when a bad actor takes power. In his second term, Trump acted fast and decisively. He ignored all conventions and many laws. He took control of all important posts, placing loyalists in charge of the military, the FBI, the Justice Department and all other important posts. And he has driven more (damaging) change than any previous President.

A bad actor in the UK would face even fewer constraints. And would not hesitate to make immediate use of all the powers at his or her disposal.

The Prime Minister should both exercise more power and cede more

So we face twin dangers: that in the short term, the government will do too little to deliver national renewal; and that in the longer term, it may be followed by an extremist government (probably far-right) which does to the UK what Trump is doing to the US. For UK citizens that would be a disaster.

We have set out how both these dangers can be avoided.

Our reports on the economics of national renewal show how the government can change the wiring of our institutions to make national renewal possible, and we have set out a Blueprint for National Renewal which shows the shape of what would be possible once that rewiring is complete.

But there is still a significant risk that, sooner or later, the UK will fall into the hands of a well-prepared extremist government. Right now, Reform, although no longer ahead in the polls, is by far the best-funded UK party. There is a new think tank set up with US funding to deliver for Reform what the Heritage Foundation delivered for Trump: a detailed plan to take control of all the levers of power and a database of candidates for the key roles throughout government. Our report on Defensive Constitutional Reform sets out tactical changes to the constitution which would limit the ability of an extremist government to destroy UK democracy.

Conclusion

So there is a real paradox of power in the UK. One which is seldom acknowledged, but is vital to the well-being of UK citizens. We need our elected representatives to address both dangers, while they have time.

If you feel this is important, please share using the buttons below, and write to your MP about it.

And join the 99% Organisation — we need your help.